Thankfully, our modern world is becoming more conscientious, and more companies are opting out of animal testing and animal-derived ingredients.
Still, it’s daunting to pick through all the varieties of toothpastes to find one that fits your lifestyle. We’ve got your back, though!
Check out our top ten picks for best vegan toothpaste.
In a Hurry? Here’s Our Quick List of Top Picks
- Desert Essence Tea Tree Oil & Neem Wintergreen Toothpaste
- JASON Sea Fresh Strengthening Fluoride-Free Toothpaste
- Redmond Peppermint Earthpaste
- Primal Life Organics Dirty Mouth Organic Toothpowder
- Lucky Teeth Remineralizing Toothpaste
- Living Libations Frankincense Fresh Truth Toothpaste
- Himalaya Herbal Healthcare Himalaya Whitening Toothpaste
- Uncle Harry’s Natural Products Natural & Fluoride-free Remineralizing Toothpaste
- Davids Natural Toothpaste
- Dr. Bronner’s Peppermint Toothpaste
10 Top Picks for Vegan Toothpastes
Desert Essence Tea Tree Oil & Neem Wintergreen Toothpaste
First off, what the heck is Neem? It’s a type of evergreen tree native to India. Its twigs are traditionally used by indigenous peoples to clean their teeth and gums.
The ayurvedic extract from the tree is used to whiten teeth, counter mouth bacteria, and freshen breath.
Combine this with the antiseptic properties of Tea Tree oil, and the bacteria that causes gingivitis and bad breath has met its match. The natural surfactants and power of baking soda give your teeth a good scrubbing, without being overly abrasive.
The pure refreshment of Wintergreen oil balances everything out, and you’ve got a zippy finish to your morning routine!
This toothpaste does everything it claims and then some. Faithful users have given glowing testimonies about the improvement of their dental health.
While it may take a bit to get used to the grittiness and slight saltiness of the baking soda, your pearly whites will be well worth the effort!
What We Like
- No animal ingredients or testing
- Fluoride-free
- No artificial flavors or dyes
- Gluten-free
- A little goes a long way
What We Don’t Like
- Contains carrageenan
- Has an acquired taste
- Somewhat salty
- May be too sudsy for some
JASON Sea Fresh Strengthening Fluoride-Free Toothpaste
Okay, so what exactly does Sea Fresh mean? Well, this toothpaste is made with ingredients sourced from the sea, including blue algae and sea salt. Both these help heal and detoxify, strengthening your gums and teeth.
JASON’s Sea Fresh also has the power of three natural whitening polishers, bamboo powder, calcium carbonate, and silica. These ingredients work together to whiten your teeth over time, without being abrasive.
Grapefruit seed and Pernilla seed extracts block sugar acids and keep harmful bacteria from forming in the nooks and crannies between your teeth. Both provide natural antimicrobials to keep those nasties at bay.
This toothpaste also has parsley. Most of us know parsley as the pretty little green plant that often ends up on the side of your fancy dinner plate.
But did you know it can help to freshen your breath and cleanse your palate? It’s not a popular garnish just for its looks!
What We Like
- Fluoride-free
- No animal-drived ingredients or testing
- No GMOs
- Gluten-free
- No artificial colors or dyes
What We Don’t Like
- Contains Carrageenan
- “Foamy” texture
- Somewhat chalky
- Some may consider it has a funky flavor
Redmond Peppermint Earthpaste
Redmond’s Peppermint Earthpaste is a unique toothpaste in that its main ingredient is clay. Why clay? You aren’t making pottery, right? Clay, and specifically bentonite clay, has 1000s of uses, and many of them are beneficial to your health.
Earthpaste uses Redmond clay, which comes from their own clay deposit in Utah. They control every aspect of the clay to product process, making this about as close to nature as you can get.
It also has the distinction of using minimal ingredients. Only water, clay, salt, xylitol, and essential oils. Five ingredients come together to make one effective toothpaste!
This toothpaste doesn’t work the way you might be used to. Without surfactants, there is no foaming, so it may feel like your teeth aren’t getting clean. However, the foam doesn’t really do anything to aid in cleansing, so there’s no need to worry.
What We Like
- Only five ingredients
- No Carrageenan, Fluoride, or surfactants
- Made in the US, with US ingredients
- No artificial anything
- No animal-derived ingredients or testing (Redmond says they only test on Redmonds, not animals!)
What We Don’t Like
- Mouth feel takes getting used to
- Foamless formula may be harsh on sensitive gums
- Unpredictable when squeezing out (Sometimes it doesn’t come out; sometimes it squirts everywhere)
- Less effective for heavy tartar or plaque
Primal Life Organics Dirty Mouth Organic Toothpowder
Dirty Mouth seems like a strange name for a tooth cleaning product, right? It gets its name from the dark color of the clay and the way it looks when you’re brushing. And no, it doesn’t taste like dirt!
This isn’t your ordinary dental hygiene product, so why have an ordinary name? Primal Life’s tooth powder is a unique product to get your chompers clean and shiny!
The ingredients are simple. Three clays (extra fine bentonite, white kaolin, and French green), aluminum-free baking soda, and essential oils. The usage is simple. Moisten your toothbrush, dip into the tub, and brush as usual.
It does take some getting used to. We have been squeezing tubes of paste onto our brushes for so long. But, once you master the method, it becomes instinctive.
The clay blend gently polishes, re-mineralizes, strengthens, whitens, and polishes your teeth. This little tub might just change the way you clean your mouth forever.
What We Like
- No artificial anything
- A little goes a long way
- 6 varieties for every taste
- No Fluoride, sweeteners, or carrageenan
What We Don’t Like
- Can be messy
- Expensive
- Learning curve for use
- May increase tooth sensitivity for some
Lucky Teeth Remineralizing Toothpaste
No products found.This organic toothpaste does more than just clean—it nourishes your entire mouth for healthier gums and stronger teeth.
A proven combination of natural ingredients work together to balance natural bacteria, fortify teeth and gums, remove stains on teeth, and feed them with minerals.
Extra virgin coconut oil cleans the teeth, gums, and tongue by extracting toxins and bacteria. Aloe vera oil eliminates disease-causing bacteria in the mouth.
Oregano oil and tea tree oil are powerful natural antiseptics. Clove and cinnamon oils are antiviral, antibacterial, antifungal, and antioxidant-packed ingredients.
Peppermint and spearmint oil help fight bad breath, gum problems, and mouth infections. These mint essential oils also provide great smell and taste.
This toothpaste also contains baking soda to kill germs and neutralize acid which can cause tooth decay, xylitol for a hint of cavity-fighting sweetness, and bentonite clay to detoxify and naturally whiten teeth.
To use, simply mix the paste to reincorporate any separated oils, place a small amount on your toothbrush, and brush until the graininess dissolves.
What We Like
- Remineralizes enamel for stronger teeth
- Naturally kills germs to fight bad breath and gum disease
- Cinnamon, clove, and mint oils provide a pleasant flavor
What We Don’t Like
- Can get messy when oils separate
- Slightly gritty texture may bother some users
- Small jar can run out quickly, especially for families
Living Libations Frankincense Fresh Truth Toothpaste
Frankincense and Myrrh have long been revered for their beneficial properties. I mean, they were presented to Baby Jesus, so they must be good!
In all seriousness, they’re amazing plants with proven positive effects on oral health.
This special toothpaste has the benefits of Frankincense, Myrrh, Tea Tree, Peppermint, and Thyme. All of which have benefits for oral care proven by scientific study.
These oils, added to a base of coconut oil, olive oil, and baking soda, create an alkaline paste that gently cleans your teeth and freshens your breath.
It comes in a cute glass jar, so no plastic waste, and is easy to use. Just apply a pea-sized dollop to your dry toothbrush and off you go!
There are no fillers in this paste, and the results speak for themselves.
Faithful users liken the Living Libations experience to a spa for your mouth! Fresh, clean, and invigorating! It compares to nothing else for oral hygiene and people are raving about it.
What We Like
- No artificial anything
- Only 7 ingredients
- Only need a tiny amount
- Proven benefits of essential oils
What We Don’t Like
- Taste may be strong and unpleasant for some
- Pricey
- May be alty
- Learning curve to adapt to its use
Himalaya Herbal Healthcare Himalaya Whitening Toothpaste
A whitening toothpaste without harmful abrasives and nasty chemicals? Sound too good to be true? Himalaya Herbal Healthcare’s toothpaste is packed with hard working natural ingredients to get your teeth the whitest they can be.
You don’t have to sacrifice the things you love about your current toothpaste; this paste foams and cleans just as good. In fact, even better.
A powerhouse team of Neem, Pomegranate, Xylitol, Pineapple and Papaya Enzymes work to get your ivories looking their best. Pineapple and Papaya Enzymes have been clinically proven to fight plaque and gingivitis!
Some customers claim it whitens wonderfully, while others say it maintains whiteness but doesn’t really whiten on its own. Stain prevention, fresher breath, and reduction of plaque were consistent in reviews.
What We Like
- No animal-drived ingredients or testing, ever!
- No SLS, carrageenan, fluoride or gluten
- Mild flavor
- Soothing, foaming formula
- Not recommended for removable denture wearers
What We Don’t Like
- Manufactured outside the US
- Essential oils used may be too overpowering for sensitive palates
- Xylitol can have an artificially overly sweet aftertaste
- Whitening effects are iffy
Uncle Harry’s Natural Products Natural & Fluoride-free Remineralizing Toothpaste
Uncle Harry’s uses simple ingredients and simple packaging to create a hard-working toothpaste.
Bentonite clay, baking soda, colloidal silver, mustard seed and essential oils refreshes your morning routine. This combo neutralizes acid and bacteria, leading to remineralization of enamel.
I love the look of Uncle Harry’s in this little jar. It adds a touch of old-fashioned class to my bathroom counter. Add that to the fact this paste does what it says, and you’ve got yourself a winner.
Harry’s provides a holistic solution for many of your oral care concerns. This toothpaste works with your alkaline saliva (promoted by the saltiness) to neutralize the acid that erodes your enamel.
So, don’t let the salty taste turn you off. It’s part of the whole shebang, and a necessary element for this product to be effective.
What We Like
- Simple, natural ingredients
- No animal testing (some of their other products use Bee Pollen and Honey, NOT this toothpaste, though)
- A little goes a long way
- Gluten, Fluoride, GMO, Glycerin-free
- Made in the US
What We Don’t Like
- Learning curve for use
- Some concern ever Colloidal Silver
- Some may consider it salty
- Some packaging issues
Davids Natural Toothpaste
If minimizing waste is just as important to you as a healthy mouth, take a gander at Davids Natural Toothpaste. The sleek metal tube is retro and recyclable, and it comes with a tube roller to squeeze out every last drop.
Davids prides themselves on quality and sustainability. They use 98% US sourced ingredients and manufacture all their products in California.
One unique certification that Davids has over all the other brands is the EWG Verification. This means the EWG (Environmental Working Group) has verified this product meets strict safety standards.
This toothpaste has the look and feel of the commercial brands you’ve been using all your life without the nasty chemicals you’re trying to avoid.
This is a great toothpaste to start with, especially if you aren’t too keen on the baking soda or clay flavors and texture of many other natural brands.
What We Like
- Made in the US with 98% US ingredients
- Fluoride, Sulfate, SLS Free
- No animal-drived ingredients or testing
- Sustainable, recyclable packaging
- Texture similar to mainstream pastes
What We Don’t Like
- Contains Carrageenan
- May be harsh for sensitive teeth
- Difficult packaging
- Foamy
Dr. Bronner’s Peppermint Toothpaste
Dr. Bronner’s was my first encounter with natural healthcare products, so it’ll always have a place in my heart. I just love the All-One packaging and their commitment to their “Cosmic Principles.”
This is a company that embodies the best in all they do. This holds true throughout all their products, and toothpaste is no exception.
This peppermint toothpaste has a texture and mouthfeel very close to what you’re used to in a mainstream brand. There is no bitterness or saltiness that lingers, and the flavors themselves are not overpowering.
Like many other natural toothpastes, Dr. Bronner’s relies on gentle abrasives to scrub teeth clean. Refreshing oils leave your mouth feeling fresh and renewed.
Faithful users agree this toothpaste has fulfilled its promises. It reduces plaque, whitens teeth, promotes fresh breath. Most users confirm their regular dental visits are more positive experiences after using this paste.
*Please note the ingredient list on Amazon is no longer accurate. Dr. Bronner’s has removed Carrageenan from all toothpaste flavors.
What We Like
- 70% Organic
- Non-GMO
- No synthetic flavors or foaming agents
- Fluoride-free
- Tastes great (All three flavors)
What We Don’t Like
- Fresh feeling isn’t super long-lasting
- Formula isn’t as thick as some expect
- Low foaming may take some getting used to
- Contains Stevia
Top Choices for Best Vegan Toothpastes
Now you’re probably eager to know which ones to choose!
The reality is, it’s a tough choice, because they’re all great options. But here are my personal favorites:
Tub Style Toothpaste:
For a tub style toothpaste, I’d definitely go with Uncle Harry’s Natural & Fluoride-free Re-Mineralizing Toothpaste.
It’s a winner for its classic look and hard-working formula. We love how it works with your own saliva to keep your smile looking great!
Tube Style Toothpaste:
And for tube style toothpaste, check out Dr. Bronner’s Peppermint Toothpaste.
This one wins for having all the natural ingredients we want, in a formula that most closely resembles what we’re used to. Plus, the company is the epitome of good business practices.
Wrapping Up
As you embark deeper into your healthy lifestyle, you will likely become aware of products don’t fit into a plant-based or vegan vision. It may alarm you to learn so many things in our day-to-day life are made with animal by-products or tested on animals “for safety.”
Animal testing has always made my skin crawl, and it’s done with many products you may not even be aware of. And really, do we need animal parts in everything?
I was taken aback when I started looking into how many daily use products have hidden animal ingredients. It seemed impossible to find things (like toothpaste) that didn’t have some unsavory ingredient or manufacturing origin.
In reality, it isn’t impossible, or very difficult to find natural alternatives anymore. The hard part is finding one that works best for you. With this roundup, we aim to shed some light on what’s out there and make navigating your way through these products a little easier.
*A note about Carrageenan: Carrageenan is a natural seaweed hand harvested from the ocean, and processed into a fine powder. It’s used as an emulsifier to bind ingredients together.
There are varying grades of Carrageenan, some of which are not suitable for food use. All of the toothpastes included use food grade Carrageenan, which is considered safe by the EWG.
Toothpaste isn’t exactly a food, so concerns about Carrageenan are minimized, as ideally, you don’t ingest the toothpaste.
This is a controversial ingredient, whether warranted or not, so we list its occurrence in the products so you can make an informed decision.
*A note about Prop 65 Warnings: You may have noticed many of the product listings on the links contain Proposition 65 warnings.
This is due to the California Law requiring all products, etc., that may contain, or have been in contact with, chemicals known to cause cancer, birth defects, or reproductive harm.
This doesn’t mean the product itself contains any of these chemicals.
We enjoyed testing these products on your behalf. Let us know which you prefer!